Financial Accounting

Inventory Write-Off vs Write-Down: Journal Entries for Damaged and Obsolete Stock

Besides SKU.io, I run a company that sells online, and for a few years our returns had a habit of disappearing. Not physically. A scratched item would come back, go on a shelf “for later” at its full cost, and sit there. When we finally went through the shelf, some of it was from 2021 and 2022. Nobody had decided anything about it, so the books still said it was worth what we paid.

Each thing on that shelf needed one of two answers, and they’re different entries.

A write-off says it’s gone: broken past selling, expired, missing. Quantity and value both come off. Seventeen mugs smashed in a dropped pallet, at $19.40 each, is a $329.80 debit to an inventory damage account and a credit to inventory. Expired stock and shrinkage get accounts of their own, which inventory shrinkage accounting lays out by reason.

A write-down says it’s still here and still sellable, but for less than it cost. The units stay. Only the value drops, to what you’ll get for them after the costs of selling them. A jacket that cost $18.00 and will now go for $14.00, with $4.00 of fees and postage, is carried at $10.00. On 200 of them that’s a $1,600.00 debit to an inventory write-downs expense account and a credit to inventory, dated the last day of the year you’re closing.

That’s the textbook part, and it’s where most explanations stop. The part that goes wrong in practice is which jackets the $1,600 lands on.

The jackets you already sold

Say those 200 jackets were the end of an order of 260. Sixty sold in the spring at full price, at a cost of $18.00 each. That cost was right then and it’s right now. The write-down is about the 200 still on the shelf at year end, and nothing about the 60 should move.

Under FIFO, though, the 260 are one layer with one cost. If the only way your system can lower a cost is to change the layer, it changes all 260. The 60 spring sales now show a cost of $10.00, margins in months you closed long ago go up, and part of the loss lands as a COGS credit instead of a write-down. Editing the original purchase bill does the same thing, and it’s the answer QuickBooks Online’s support team gave a user in 2021 who wanted to lower an inventory value without changing the quantity: adjust the purchase. (Since 2026, QuickBooks Online companies on moving average cost can adjust value directly. FIFO companies still can’t.)

The jackets sold after year end are the other half. If you post the December 31 write-down in mid-January, the ones that sold on January 5 were on the shelf on December 31, so they should carry the written-down cost, not $18.00. If January is already locked, that means reopening it, and that’s the moment people are tempted to skip it.

The worst fix I’ve heard of, from more than one seller, is to “sell” the stock on a made-up sales order to clear it out of the FIFO queue and then receive it back at the lower cost. It works, in the sense that the cost comes down. It also records revenue and a customer that don’t exist, puts the loss in COGS next to real sales, and tells next year’s aging report that two-year-old stock arrived yesterday.

Writing down why

An apparel owner who keeps her own books described her year-end decision the way most sellers make it: “So instead of $30, now we value it at $25, and we just ride that.” That’s a write-down, and a reasonable one. What makes it hold up is one line saying where the $25 came from: a price list, a clearance price, an offer from a liquidator. If a sale in the first week of January moves the stock at a lower price than you guessed, and nothing changed in between, that sale is the better evidence. Use it.

Some accountants book the credit to an inventory reserve, a contra account beside inventory, instead of inventory itself. That’s a fine way to present it. If your inventory system costs by layer, though, keep the lower cost on the layers and let the reserve be a presentation, or the valuation report and the inventory account are apart by the reserve every month and someone has to keep that line in step.

Whether the value can go back up later depends on your standard, and so does the tax treatment. Both are in the year-end guide.

Seconds, and stock you haven’t seen

The case in between is the scratched return. It can still sell, as a second, for less. Restock it as its own “blemished” product at its original cost, then write that product down. If you lower the cost on the original product instead, the cut doesn’t stay with the scratched unit: under average costing it drags down every good unit beside it, and under FIFO it lands on whichever units sell next.

Then sell it. Seconds nobody owns sit at full cost, which is how ours got to two and three years old. We auction them now, mostly on eBay, and reviewing the aging report is a standing job for one person on the team. Before that, the write-downs we should have taken in the first month arrived years later, in one lump, the year we finally cleared the shelf.

Stock you haven’t seen is the one I’d argue about. Amazon will mark stock “unsellable” that turns out to be brand new when it comes back. We once considered writing all of it down at a flat rate and dropped the idea, because we’d have valued it twice, once blind and again when we could see it. The year end still wants a number for it, so use what your last few removal orders turned out to be worth once you opened the boxes. If you’ve never tracked that, start with the next one.

How SKU.io handles it

Losses post to their own accounts by reason, set up in the guide to sending inventory losses to their own accounts. A write-down is a separate document that lowers only the units on hand at the date, keeps each layer’s date so aging doesn’t reset, and shows the journal and the January sales it will re-cost before it posts. There’s no separate reserve: stock value is the sum of the layers, checked against your inventory account. The steps are in write down inventory at year end.

If you sell under about $1M a year on one channel, a write-off account and a year-end journal in your accounting software will do, and Zoho Inventory or inFlow will hold the stock. If seconds and slow stock are a steady part of your year, book a demo and bring last year’s write-down.

This post is part of two guides: inventory write-downs at year end, which covers finding and pricing the stock, approvals and disclosure, and inventory shrinkage accounting, which covers the losses.

Newsletter

Get the next one by email

Short, practical writing on inventory, fulfilment and multi-channel operations — sent when there is something worth sending.

Double opt-in — we send a confirmation link and you are not on the list until you click it. One-click unsubscribe on every email. See our privacy policy.

Ready to see SKU.io in action?

Bring your real numbers and the messy questions — we'll walk the system against an operation like yours, not a slide deck.

Book a Demo

Founder-led demo · 2-day onboarding · no onboarding fees