Are Inventory Write-Downs Tax Deductible? Book vs Tax at Year End
An apparel owner told me why she writes stock down at year end: “we were profitable. I may as well take the hit and lower my profit. But truly I should because it was lowered value.” Both halves of that are reasonable, and they pull in different directions. The second half is accounting: the stock really is worth less, so the books should say so. The first half is tax, and in the US a write-down on your books doesn’t automatically lower the tax bill.
This is about US federal income tax. It isn’t tax advice, and your CPA decides how it applies to you.
Book profit and taxable income follow different rules
On the books, stock costed by FIFO or average cost is carried at the lower of cost and net realizable value, and a write-down to that value is an expense this year. For tax, inventory is valued at cost or at lower of cost or market, and “market” under Treasury Regulation §1.471-4 normally means what it would cost you to buy the goods again at the inventory date. It doesn’t mean what customers will pay. If you use LIFO for tax, §1.472-2 says inventory is taken “at cost regardless of market value,” so a falling market gives you no write-down there.
That gap is where most year-end write-downs live. Take 200 of last season’s jackets. They cost you $18 and you could buy them again for about $18. They’ll only sell for $14 now. Your books say they’re worth $10 after selling costs. The tax rules, for normal goods, still say $18.
What the Supreme Court said in Thor Power Tool
The case everyone cites is Thor Power Tool Co. v. Commissioner, decided in 1979. Thor wrote down what it considered excess inventory to its own estimate of what the goods would sell for. It didn’t scrap them and it didn’t cut their prices: it kept them for sale at the original prices. The IRS disallowed the write-down, and the Supreme Court sided with the IRS. The write-down followed generally accepted accounting principles, and that didn’t matter. For tax, an estimate that the stock is worth less isn’t enough while you’re still asking full price for it.
So “we have too much of this and it’s slow” is a book write-down and, usually, not a deduction.
When a write-down does reduce taxable income
Three situations get you there.
You actually sell or scrap the stock. The loss is real once the goods are gone. Sell the jackets at $9 in March and the lower margin is in March’s taxable income. Destroy them and the cost goes with them. This is what we do at my other company with aged returns: they go to auction, mostly on eBay. For tax it’s the cleanest answer there is, because the sale is the deduction and the auction is the record of the price.
The goods are “subnormal” and you offer them at the lower price. Under §1.471-2(c), goods that can’t be sold at normal prices because of damage, imperfections, shop wear, changes of style, odd or broken lots, or similar causes can be valued at a bona fide selling price less the direct cost of disposing of them. A bona fide selling price means an actual offering of the goods during a period ending no later than 30 days after the inventory date. Last season’s jackets are a change of style. If your inventory date is December 31 and they’re listed at $14 by January 30, with $4 of selling costs, they can be valued at $10 for tax too, and the $1,600 write-down is deductible. If they’re still listed at $24.99, it isn’t.
Replacement cost fell. If you already value inventory at lower of cost or market for tax (switching to it is a change of accounting method, which needs the IRS’s consent) and the price you’d pay your supplier dropped, that drop can come off. It’s a purchase-price change, not a selling-price one.
Small businesses have another option
Section 471(c) lets a business that meets the gross receipts test in section 448(c) account for inventory in ways the rules above don’t, including following its applicable financial statement or, without one, its own books and records. How far that reaches for a write-down is set out in the 2021 regulations under it, and it’s a question for your CPA with your books in front of them.
What to keep
The evidence for the tax side is the same evidence that supports the books, so collect it once:
- the list of what you wrote down, with the cost and the new value per item;
- where each new value came from: your own listing at the lower price and the date it went up, a clearance price list, a liquidator’s offer;
- for damaged or shop-worn goods, a note or photo of the condition;
- anything scrapped, with dates and quantities.
Then tell your CPA the book number and the tax number separately. The difference between them is a book–tax difference they reconcile on your return, and it’s easier to handle in January than to reconstruct in April.
How SKU.io handles the evidence
When you write stock down to net realizable value in SKU.io, each line keeps the price source, the price and the costs to sell that produced its value, and the write-down’s schedule exports them line by line for your accountant. It doesn’t decide what’s deductible and it isn’t tax software. The steps are in write down inventory at year end, and the rest of the year end, from pricing the stock to disclosure, is in inventory write-downs at year end.
If your year-end write-down is a few products and a journal, your CPA and a spreadsheet will do. If it’s hundreds of SKUs across channels, book a demo and bring last year’s.